From 1380cc82cd19fe08e85cf90fe935f33a68c357b7 Mon Sep 17 00:00:00 2001 From: Holden Rohrer Date: Thu, 30 Apr 2020 23:07:45 -0400 Subject: added basic dbq outlines --- wroblewski-world/dbqs.txt | 100 ++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++ 1 file changed, 100 insertions(+) create mode 100644 wroblewski-world/dbqs.txt diff --git a/wroblewski-world/dbqs.txt b/wroblewski-world/dbqs.txt new file mode 100644 index 0000000..a9f2c16 --- /dev/null +++ b/wroblewski-world/dbqs.txt @@ -0,0 +1,100 @@ +Unit 1 +------ + +Document 1: +Matthew is recounting, 80 years after the fact, in the classical age, +Jesus's lesson against the overaccumulation of wealth. This seems to +warn against mercantile activity. + +Document 2: +The Qur'an, including parts of the bible, encourages merchants but +qualifies it with "honest, truthful." +At the time silk road was developing (??) + +Document 3: +Christian British Merchant. +Treats being a merchant as a valuable occupation. +Doesn't contradict "rich man cannot enter heaven." + Sold all possessions and gave to poor--- + means that he wants to look good in eyes of god. + Believes that making money for the lord is godly. +At the time, Britons were exploring mkts. +Reginald, contemporary likely wanted to portray in good light to (king? church?) + +Document 4: +Muslim scholar degrades merchant class. +Audience unclear ( Universal History = People at large? ). +Probably writing on behalf of ruler/king, so portraying elite well. +Probably also wants to increase own stature. +But does not say cannot exist because the unvirtuous working class + works on behalf of the elite + +Document 5: +Seljuqs took over from Abbasids which were weakening. +Silk clothing requires trade. +Many luxury goods provided for ruler with attendants. +Manuscript = inform people of power/wealth of ruler. +Indirectly portrays Muslim (regional) traders in a good light +because they brought all this wealth at good deals. + +Thesis: +Muslims promoted bartering and the gain of individual money because +caliphs and their servants wanted to obtain wealth for the advancement +of their people, unlike Christians who don't trust merchants readily, +and require work beyond their basic responsibilities (charity, poverty). + +Possible Groups: +Christian/Muslim. +Merchants are good inherently. +Merchants are bad inherently. +Merchants are good only if they serve god. +Elite +Religious/Lower Class + +Unit 2 +------ + +Document 1: +Marco Polo is describing trade goods which are transported to these +cities or manufactured there. Mongol Silk Road allowed travel of these +goods easily as well as travel of the info (Historical Context). +Talking well about Chinese area to wider (Oceania, ME) audience that +being under Mongol rule is good (already controlled but less central) +Religious tolerance is high. + +Document 2: +Christian church currently controls the majority of Europe. +Mongols control rest of world. Mongols tolerate Christians well w/o +religious intent of their own. +Mongols made Silk road more safe and became wealthy based on it. + +Document 3: +Brutal warriors well-feared, the Mongols demanded tributes of thinkers. +Brought together many people because they didn't have internal agrarian +culture (nomad warriors). +Probably attempting to portray Mongols in a negative light because +Russians were very anti-Mongol. + +Document 4: +Religious tolerances happened around the world. This document, though, +probably wants to present Khanate well (calls Khan World Conqueror and +is in position of power). +Silver balish = development of education and institution. + +Document 5: +Power against city walls demonstrated here. +A single ruling organization means that Khanate was far above common +folk in terms of weaponry => strong merchant unity. + +Thesis: +The Mongols united many thinkers of the classical world to develop +sciences and arts; they reduced trade barriers significantly which +built up the merchant class, luxury goods, and production centres. +However, unlike other large empires (like Abbassid), the Mongols were +very religiously tolerant, which propagated to more secular traditions +in China region. + +Groups: +Silk road safety => wealth develpoment. +Unite thinkers, etc. +Secular tradition/religious tolerance. -- cgit