diff options
author | Holden Rohrer <hr@hrhr.dev> | 2020-12-02 18:57:31 -0500 |
---|---|---|
committer | Holden Rohrer <hr@hrhr.dev> | 2020-12-02 18:57:31 -0500 |
commit | e2d11024d8ab3a5c486017d5b23fef5aaa8fcf03 (patch) | |
tree | 1a30d7e53e29c5b2773c03f7294e088f1ad7205d | |
parent | e0709f7da57c250127b4ba10fd57b4b584a3be3c (diff) |
i'm giving up on the cover essay
114 words left, but they'd be trash anyway. too tired to think.
-rw-r--r-- | markley/portfolio/01_cover_essay.html | 101 |
1 files changed, 100 insertions, 1 deletions
diff --git a/markley/portfolio/01_cover_essay.html b/markley/portfolio/01_cover_essay.html index f27a370..90648c1 100644 --- a/markley/portfolio/01_cover_essay.html +++ b/markley/portfolio/01_cover_essay.html @@ -110,4 +110,103 @@ and the workplace.</li> </tbody> </table> - +<p> +The references I'm creating in the digital reading journal feeds into +the reading responses, which are essentially final artifacts. +The reading responses are one to three page essays about how the content +and concepts in books we've read for class relate to health as a +collection of social ideals. +The reading responses are exercises in critical thinking, and those +ideas are channeled into an argumentative essay. +The questions are phrased such that a student must take a stance like +"strangeness is a sign of moral contradiction" (the stance I took in +the first reading response) and defend it. +Rhetoric is useful here, and tailoring the language style to the +audience and the situation means a formal style of argument where +organization is critical. +</p> +<p> +<!-- + What kind of rhetoric is required for the essay? How is it different + from the digital reading journal? + What changes could I have made to fit the rhetoric better in either + one? + ?How could I have improved my process? + Talk a lot more about the revision activities. + Hmm..what is the kind of understanding that I develop with health? + As a proxy for social norms, what does that tell me about general + critical analysis? + Okay so this class has taught me about analyzing the implicit claims + and social structures. Also "language, knowledge, and power" +--> +Organizing the essay means ordering the ideas, with transitions, inside +paragraphs and selecting the right subtopics to focus on creates a much +stronger argument for the thesis of the essay, and the revision +activities are about this aspect of text organization. +They build on the reading response essays by asking students to review +the paragraph structure (in terms of abstraction from direct evidence to +general claims) and how well those paragraphs put the argument forward. +With unlimited time, I might have improved my reading response essays +further with these techniques, but these are valuable to me going +forwards as a formulaic way to review part of the quality of an essay's +rhetoric +</p><p> +The reading responses are process documents in one other way: they are a +segment of the semester-long process to fully understand the ideal of +health. +This course introduced me to this incredibly comprehensive system of +"process," and I think it's an incredibly useful lens for writing and +research, so I will try to frame larger writing projects I have in terms +of a more effective process than "just write it." +</p><p> +The Process and Rhetoric Outcomes are very important for developing a +presentable piece, but the major ideas of the course are backed by the +Critical Thinking Outcome. +Health is one possible lens for social analysis, but it's a particularly +wide-reaching one because health is essentially a linguistic proxy for +social norms---the healthful is the socially normative. +However, the power dynamics (black-white, female-male) we studied are +general rather than medicine-specific, and analyzing society through the +lens of privileged and unprivileged. +One tool for reviewing social systems that I found very valuable from +this course is how culture pervades language and reflects the status +quo. +See the portrayal of Hyde as disgusting, hideous, and <em>unhealthy</em> +in the first Reading Response as an example. +This portrayal reflects a culture which views moral virtues as first and +foremost to leading a good life. +Hyde, the person made of pure evil, was a murderer and a thief, which +makes him an unhealthy person---which is why a drug regime and eventual +demise are associated with the indiscretion of becoming Hyde, like a +poetic punishment. +</p> +<iframe src="https://hrhr.dev/essayone" height=600 width=800></iframe> +<p> +The specific theme of health is fairly domain-specific, but these +modes of thinking are general. +When an author talks about a character or any other element of the story +with language like Robert Louis Stevenson uses, it is clear that the +character is meant to be a figure of whatever the author considers to be +ultimate evil, which differs culturally. +I also analyze language in the second reading response essay, but I use +it to talk about the implied social claim against experimenters from +<em>The Island of Dr. Moreau</em> to argue about the experimenter's +psychology or at least the public perception thereof is one tied down to +rules-based thinking. +I argue that the reason experimenters don't become Dr. Moreau vivisector +types is that they are bound by laws, threats to remove funding, and +strict social norms on consent. +I use the implied moral feeling on experimenters of <em>The Island</em> +to disambiguate why doctors abuse African-American patients the way they +do according to <em>Medical Apartheid</em>. +I conjoined these analyses with a third argument about the nature of +experiment to show that experimenters, by default, want the most control +they can have over their experiments, and ethical concerns take a +backseat. +</p> +<iframe src="https://hrhr.dev/markley/essaytwo"></iframe> +<p> +<!-- most important concepts, strategies, skills, practices, approaches +that you acquired, in relation both to the course outcomes and to your +own priorities as a student. +I'm talking about rhetoric and process. Have mostly talked about DRJ--> |