1
2
3
4
5
6
7
8
9
10
11
12
13
14
15
16
17
18
19
20
21
22
23
24
25
26
27
28
29
30
31
32
33
34
35
36
37
38
39
40
41
42
43
44
45
46
47
48
49
50
51
52
53
54
55
56
57
58
59
60
61
62
63
64
65
66
67
68
69
70
71
72
73
74
75
76
77
78
79
80
81
82
83
84
85
86
87
88
89
90
91
92
93
94
95
96
97
98
99
100
101
102
103
104
105
106
107
108
109
110
111
112
113
114
115
116
117
118
119
120
121
122
123
124
125
126
127
128
129
130
131
132
133
134
135
136
137
138
139
140
141
142
143
144
145
146
147
148
149
150
151
152
153
154
155
156
157
158
159
160
161
162
163
164
165
166
167
168
169
170
171
172
173
174
175
176
177
178
179
180
181
182
183
184
185
186
187
188
189
190
191
192
|
Europe tumbles when US crashes.
- Develops fascism, naziism, communism
FDR believed large corporations were to blame for the economic state,
which could only be solved by an active preseident and a strong govt.
- American Gov't had a responsibilty to help people in distress
- passed dozens of measures to promote welfare and economic recovery
- Not specifically ideological, but a pragmatist
- New Deal (ND) was experimental, some programs failed miserably
Herbert Hoover just didn't want to do anything
- Andrew Mellon wanted to liquidate {real estate, stocks, farmers}
- Let the capitalist system "purge itself of rottenness"
- Invited business, agricultural, unions to talk (later)
- Encouraged them to stop strikes, maintain employment
- "Ineffective cheerleader for capitalism"
- Provided no direct federal relief
- biggest emergency since the Civil War
- Passed 1932 Revevue Act: huge tax increase
- worsened economic slowdown
- Pushed "self-reliance" narrative
- believed in charities, voluntarism
- New Dem Congress forced Hoover to Reconstruction Finance Corporation
- helped out big banks, railroads
- Dems still questioned these policies
- Hoover only allowed RFC to make loans to states
- Hoover did not take it as a sign
Bonus Army March
- Wanted Congress to pay veterans the 4 million cash bonuses they
promised for 1935
- It is actually 1932, but the House authorized it (Senate denied)
- Veterans with no place to go camped in vacant buildings,
shantytown (first nonviolent protestors in US)
- Congress paid for train tickets home
- William Mitchell, Attorney General, ordered buildings cleared
- Secretary of War dispatched soldiers to remove them
- Horses, tanks, tear gas
- General MacArthur
- Soldiers, exceeding orders, burned their encampment
- PR disaster for Hoover + Republicasn (heartless)
- Hoover became tired and poor morale
- said he "had no Wilsonian qualities"
- terrible, cold speaker
1032 Election: FDR met public demand for change (Hoover lost)
- FDR is NY governor
- Said his campaign was a "call to arms"
- Wanted new ideas and agressive action
- Hoover lacked vitality and vision
Roosevelt's First 100 Days
- Asked for broad power from Congress to respond to the emergency
- Chicago Tribune, Repub newspaper, praised him
- Presidency defined by leadership and action
- He and his advisors wanted to build back the economy and help those in
need
- "Our greatest primary task is putting people to work" - FDR
- Gave farmers money to make less crops
- 100 First Days: created 50 programs, some of which to become the ND
- Hundreds of banks were failing
- FDR asked Congress to pass "Emergency Banking Relief Act"
- 4 day bank holiday to stall the bank collapse
- Funded banks to restore confidence
- "Safer to keep your money in a reopened bank than in your
mattress"
- Removed Gold Standard
- Glass-Steagall Banking Act
- Created Federal Deposit Insurance Incorporation (FDIC) to
isnure up to 250K.
- Divided savings banks from investment banks. Only investment
banks could invest in stock mkt after 1933
- Securities Act of 1933 regulated sales of stocks and bonds
- Required publicly traded companies to disclose all relevant
information
- Securities Exchange Commission (SEC) enforces this.
- Helping the Unemployed and Homeless
- Federal Emergency Relief Act (FERA) gave money to states for
unemployed and homeless
- Proved ineffective
- First large-scale effort to put people on gov't payroll at good
wages: Civil Works Admin.
- Civilian Conservation Corps (CCC) managed by War Dept. employed
unmarried unemployed young men as "Soil Soldiers" ($1/day for no
more than 9mo)
- Cleared brush, constructed roads, trees, parks, taught farmers
- National Industrial Recovery Act (NIRA) established PWA (sewage
plants, dams, highways) and National Recovery Administration (NRA)
- NRA set prices, wages, and working standards --- unique for
the government in peacetime
- NRA codes included fair labor policies (like 40hr/8hr, no
child labor, unionization), negotiation policies
- Supreme Court declared it unconstitutional because it
would be a Congressional responsibility
- Some NRA policies had lasting effects like
national minimum wage, workweek
- Farm Credit Administration and Agricultural Adjustment Act/Adm
(AAA)
- FCA bailed out farmers so they didn't lose homes, farms
- AAA paid farmers to destroy cotton crop
- Pigs were slaughtered and buried
- Wheat, cotton, corn production declined, prices rose
- In the first 100 days, FDR gained the most pulbic support
- Most loved by the people
- Twice weekly press conferences won over journalists
- Very visible to the people
- Hated by some people
- Leftists criticized him for not doing enough (decline slowed,
but prosperity remained elusive)
- Conservatives believed he was bringing in socialism
- Prone to idealistic principles and pragmatic politics, allowing
compromise and contradiction
Huey Long, enemy of FDR
- Classic Demagogue/populist appealing to the people
- Wore pink shirts, pastel ties
- King Fish of Louisiana
- Used bribery, intimidation and blackmail to support his policies
- Funded schools, lowered taxes
- Jealous of FDR.
- "Share the Wealth Society"
- Wanted to raise taxes on wealthiest Americans and redistribute
thousands to the poorest
- May have unseated Roosevelt
- Roosevelt called the senator one of the two most dangerous in the
country
Father Charles Coughlin, the other most dangerous man
- Fiery Roman Catholic radio priest
- Criticized Roosevelt as "anti-god" pushing Communist conspiracy
- that he wanted to put oil companies, big companies, and god-given
resources under gov't control
- Very anti-semitic, which forced radio stations to drop him by 40s
- In 30s, he was going strong however
The Court was strongly opposing Roosevelt's New Deal and Congress's
support of him
- Businesses were filing lawsuits that allowed this
- Ex: Court unanimously killed NIRA, saying it violated anti-trust
- US v Butler: tax on middlemen (warehouses, processors) in Agricultural
Adjustment Act unconstitutional
- 7 of 9 cases, SC ruled against ND.
- Second New Deal tried to undermine the appeal of Huey Long
- Banking reforms, taxes on wealthy, continue employing people
- Works Progress Administration (WPA) employs hugely: increases by 2
million people each year
- NLRA "Wagner" Act guaranteed workers the right to unionize and
protected them. Required businesses to act in good faith.
- Social Security Act: old age pensions and unemployment relief
(insurance) through wage and payroll taxes
- Only by 1950s did it become seen as primary source of
retirement income, previously supplemental
- Conservative compared to European countries: other countries
used general funds instead of payroll taxes; also used a
regressive flat tax
- Removed a lot of money from circulation, hurting economy
- Excluded about half of workers
- Wealth-Tax "Soak the rich" Act
- Raised taxes on evasive rich
- Called communism; Roosevelt responds that he wanted to "save
capitalism" by supporting a more equal dist. of wealth
Huey Long assassinated in 1939. Roosevelt wins in a landslide against
Alf Landon
- Keeps huge Democrat majority in Congress
- Constructs a new Democrat political bloc
Court-packing
- If Congress enlarged the Court, it wouldn't block the Second ND
- Wanted 6 new justices, one for each over 75 years old
- Backfired; public focused on constitutionality of proposal
- Congressional Reps and Dems decided it was too controversial
- Justices began to uphold SS Act, Wagner Act.
- One conservative justice resigned, replaced by Roosevelt with a
New Dealer
Evaluating the New Deal
- Economy began to grow around 1939, so gov't stopped spending,
increasing unemployment, tumbling the economy
- Roosevelt relaunched federal spending
- Housing funding
- Conservative Southern Democrats balked at Northerners and
African-Americans, acting against New Deal
- Congressional elections of 1938 lost many seats to Reps
- Roosevelt began speaking about "preserving" reforms instead of
expanding
- Stalemate
- "more energy than coherence"
- But it did improve life in many ways: worker protections, bank regs,
public health
- Demonstrated that American Democracy could handle a collapse of
capitalism
- 10M Americans still remained unemployed
- Halfway Revolution was its longlasting impact
|
